- Published on
"I feel...like it's my fault," Bea said, "everyone tells me not to feel that way, but I do. I took something that was important to her, something she had, in theory, been doing already for an extended period of time, and I gave it to others. It was a betrayal, and in hindsight, she had every single right to be mad at me about. In turn, I'm mad at Michelle because she told me that Casey, and her emotions, were not my responsibility, but the thing is...they weren't anyones. She had no family. No romantic partner. She had nobody but me. So, if she wasn't my responsibility, whose was she? Her own? No. That's callous. Nobody should be alone."
The therapist nodded, taking it all in as Bea and Leslie sat on the couch together. Ever since Casey had killed herself, the two of them had made it a habit of coming here once a week to try and work through Bea's grief. Thusfar, however, it hadn't really been all that successful and endeavor, sad to say.
"I understand that your entire...schtick, so to speak, is caring about everyone, especially kids who had nobody else to care about them, but-"
"It isn't a goddamn 'schtick'," Bea grumbled, Leslie and the therapist exchanging a glance, indicating the therapist had indeed messed up with that verbiage; they tapped their pen on their clipboard a few times anxiously and quickly course corrected.
"Um, right, I'm sorry, I apologize. But even still, she wasn't a child. She was a grown adult," the therapist said.
"Was she?" Bea asked, "because trauma stunts the developmental process. So, sure, from the outside they may look like adults, but emotionally, psychologically, they're still the terrified little kids they were when the trauma occured. Saying she was a grown adult is only accurate if you're speaking of her physiologically."
Leslie exhaled and took one of Bea's hands in her own, squeezing gently.
"Hey," she said softly, "you cannot save everyone."
"I have to," Bea said, on the verge of totaling losing it, "I have to, cause nobody else will."
Her thoughts turned from Casey to Liam, to their daughter. Every single time she closed her eyes lately, she saw her little girl. She saw the day they left her. She saw the betrayal, front and center. Seemed all she'd done her life was betray little girls. Maybe that was why she'd attached herself so tightly to Michelle, because in a way, she saw a woman who hadn't really had a mother, and so in a sense, Beatrice could make up for her past mistakes.
"Does Michelle know about this?" the therapist asked and Bea scoffed, chuckling, shaking her head.
"We've barely spoken since the incident. We spoke at the speech, but that was about it. Since then I've kind of kept my distance, which I'm sure has hurt her but...it's better this way, cause I know...I know that the next time I see her face..." Bea stumbled for words, biting her lip, "...will be the last time I see her face."
***
Michelle was standing outside The Hole.
The lot was busy, bustling, preparing for the next shoot, but Michelle wasn't involving herself, opting instead to stand outside The Hole and simply stare at a nearby billboard featuring Bea's face. She was chewing gum as she stared at the billboard, featuring Bea, Liam's character and a few other puppets, advertising the show, and she shook her head as the doors to The Hole opened and Eliza stepped outside.
"Did you wanna come back in?" Eliza asked, wrapping her arms around Michelle's waist from behind, hugging her, "it's cold, and I could make you warm."
"I don't even think being here is good for me," Michelle said.
"Was it Keagan?"
"I mean it's not her fault someone sought her out as a line to Bea," Michelle said, shrugging, "that's what Keagan does, she...she finds things. That's how this all started. I can't blame her, she's my friend, and she's an unwilling participant. No. It's Bea's fault. It's Bea's fucking fault for doing this in the first place, for creating this landmine that was set to detonate at a later point in time, taking out everyone around her with it."
Eliza pulled away and looked at the Liam puppet under her arm, before sliding it back onto her arm and raising it up, standing in front of Michelle now.
"Don't be mad at her," Eliza said, pretending the puppet was talking, making Michelle smile softly, "she was young, she didn't mean to. You can't blame someone for something they didn't mean to do. Ask Eliza, she would know."
Michelle's eyes moved from the puppet up to Eliza's face, her eyes now cast to the ground, making Michelle slightly nervous. Was Eliza using this puppet as a way to work through things, or was this a subconscious thing she wasn't aware she was doing, thinking this puppet was actually Liam? Her heart ached at the idea of the second being true.
"He's right," Eliza said quietly, still looking at her shoes, "it isn't her fault. And even if it were, it's only partially, cause there's still the dad to blame, whoever he ends up being, if it even matters. But he's right."
Michelle pushed the puppet down a bit and took Eliza's soft face in her hands, pulling her in close and kissing her softly. Eliza blushed and gave in, her knees buckling as she leaned into it, so happily kissing Michelle back. Michelle and Eliza rested their foreheads against one another, both trying not to giggle uncontrollably.
"You make me feel so grounded in a world of uncertainty," Michelle said.
"And you make me feel like there's more to me than my work," Eliza replied.
"I love you, baby," Michelle whispered.
"I love you too," Eliza said, before holding the Liam puppet back up and adding, "and I love you both!" making Michelle cackle. Just then a car came screeching to a halt in the lot, almost doing a donut as it stopped, causing Michelle and Eliza to look up, surprised by the sudden noise and arrival. The car idled momentarily before turning off and the door opening, Justine stumbling out. She was wearing a pleated grey pencil skirt, a blue button down blouse with a cream colored houndstooth cardigan over it, her hair looking as though she'd at least tried to make it into a bun but had done so sloppily. She stood and stared at the girls over the roof of her car.
"Justine?" Michelle asked, "what are you doing here?"
Justine turned and looked up at the billboard, then pointed at it.
"Fuck that dog!" she shouted, making Michelle laugh nervously to herself.
***
"I don't know what to do," Leslie said, sounding exhausted, as she sank back into the couch. Bea had retreated to the restroom momentarily, leaving the therapist and Leslie alone. The therapist nodded, bouncing their knee as Leslie continued, adding, "I've...I feel, like, fuck, I've done all I can at this point, and it's absolutely killling me to watch this and what the guilt is doing to her."
"Until she accepts it wasn't her fault she won't move forward, it's simple as that," the therapist said.
"I don't think she can," Leslie said, "I genuinely...knowing her intimately, loving her, I don't think she's capable of allowing herself that grace. She's too harsh on herself."
The door opened and Bea quietly slipped back inside, shutting it gently behind herself. She then seated herself back on the couch beside Leslie, who leaned in and planted a small kiss on her cheek, making Bea smile and blush, just a little.
"Beatrice," the therapist said, "you grew up with a good family. Great parents. Where do you think this need to be a mother to every little girl comes from?"
Bea knew the answer, but admitting to it would forever change her relationship with Leslie, as well as Leslie's perception of her as a whole. No. She couldn't have that. She wouldn't. Bea shook her head and shrugged. Perpetuate the lie to keep the peace. That had always been their plan. Now, with Liam gone, the responsibility fell to her and her alone, even if it meant isolating the ones she loved around her further.
"It can't just be related to the show, to the morals you want to express," the therapist said, "because it obviously runs so deep in your soul, or else you wouldn't be feeling this way and doing it to such a degree offscreen. I'm just...I'm trying to figure out the source. Help me, Bea, so I can help you, and we can help eachother."
"There's nothing to figure out," Bea whispered, eyes looking at her hands between her legs, "please stop looking. I'm as plain as day."
Leslie felt her heart hurt just a little more. Beatrice sounded so wounded, so run down. But, as the therapist had said, without her cooperation, all their efforts were moot. Bea put her hands in her hair and started crying, making Leslie lean over and pull her head to her chest, rocking her gently.
"There there, I've got you," Leslie said softly.
"I'm a bad person," Bea whispered through her tears, her breathing shaky, her voice weak.
"Why do you say that, sweetheart?" Leslie asked.
But Bea, as per usual in these sessions, didn't elaborate. Elaborating meant facing the truth, and the truth would tear her whole world apart. No. Stoicism in the face of uncertainty, that was the path forward.
No matter what the cost.
***
"Goddamn dog came into my home, cleaned up my kitchen, removed all my alcohol!" Justine shouted as she stumbled towards Eliza and Michelle, "who is she to have such moral superiority!? As if she's better than me."
"Did you drive here drunk?" Michelle asked, now sounding more concerned than finding it amusing as she had before; she lowered her voice even more to spare Justine the embarrassment, adding, "Justine, did you drive here intoxicated? When did you start drinking?"
"When did I stop?" Justine asked loudly, "I'm drunk from the moment I wake up to the moment I fall asleep, and it wasn't an issue until she decided to stop by and take it upon herself to act like a goddamn AA sponsor!"
"I'm...going to go inside," Eliza said sheepishly, backing away. Michelle understood, and didn't stop her.
"This is serious, you cannot be driving under the influence," Michelle said, "for fucks sake, Justine, there's schools between here and there, not to mention the people who bring their kids to the lot. Or even hurting other drivers, pedestrians, yourself."
"As if hurting myself would be bad," Justine said, taking Michelle by surprise. Justine walked, or rather shambled, over to the nearby wall and leaned against it, sliding down it as she cried softly, "it's one thing to lose someone once, but to lose someone twice? That's...that is a loss that is insurmountable. I didn't have a choice in losing him, that was an accident, that was the result of weather and poor plane maintenance. But her?"
She didn't even need to say their name. Michelle knew all too well.
"...she didn't have to die," Justine continued, her voice so weak and soft, as if she were scared of hearing herself, "she didn't have to die, and she did, and it's my fault, and I could've stopped it. I couldn't stop the other one but I could've stopped this. But she's dead. She jumped off that bridge thinking nobody loved her. She was my friend. She was my friend, and I killed her. I was selfish for an hour and I killed her."
Michelle approached the wall and sat down beside Justine. Justine fall into Michelle, sobbing against her shoulder, as Michelle reached up and ran her fingers through her hair.
"You didn't kill her. She killed herself," Michelle said, "that's a distinction you need to recognize. Your actions didn't motivate that. After learning what her life had been like, I...I can't say I was too surprised. I mean I was surprised in the moment, cause, yeah, you never expect that. But in hindsight? Fuck. Impressive she made it that far, even. You didn't kill her, Justine."
"Why..." Justine asked, looking up at Michelle now, their eyes locking, as she uttered, in the lowest voice possible, "...why does everyone I love keep dying?"
That did it. That broke her. Michelle herself was now feeling tears form on her face.
"Uh," she said, wiping her face on her other arm, "um, fuck. I can't answer that, I'm sorry. I...I genuinely wish that I could, but I can't. If it's any consolation, though, it happens to everyone. Everyone that loves others loses them to death eventually."
Justine grabbed Michelle's arm and cried even harder. Michelle exhaled.
"I know how you feel," she continued, "I know it's not the exact same, Casey and I didn't really have the working relationship that you two did, but I know how you feel. After she died, I took it upon myself to bring Beatrice back from the brink of a breakdown once Liam left, and I...I need to save those around me, because I pushed Casey away from the production. I was the one who told Bea not to worry about her, which sent her spiraling, and onto your doorstep. You wanna blame someone for what happened? Fucking blame me, okay?"
Justine looked up at Michelle, their eyes meeting yet again.
"You didn't kill her, Justine, I did," Michelle said, crying now too, "and I'm gonna pay for that for the rest of my life, or die trying to save everyone else instead."
Another car pulled up and Beatrice climbed out.
"The hell is going on out here?" she asked.
Michelle stared Bea down.
"I have something you need to see," Michelle said flatly.
***
Inside The Hole, Eliza was sitting at her work desk, staring at the Liam puppet, still on her hand, raised to eye level.
"I can't help them," Eliza said.
"You can, you just don't know how to yet," the Liam puppet said.
"No," she shook her head, "I love Michelle so much, but I can't help her. I can't even cope with you being gone. That's why you're here now. And if...if she ever gets the idea of what you are, to me, then that's going to scare her and make her stop loving me."
"You know that girl could never stop loving you," the Liam puppet said, and Eliza lowered him onto the table, pulling him off her arm and laying him there. She leaned back on her chair, pulling her legs up into her chest and wrapping her arms around them, a physicality she always retreated to when things got scary. She knew the puppet wasn't talking. She wasn't hearing his voice. She was simply utilizing it in a way that helped her cope with the grief of his absence. Besides Bea, and her family, Liam was the only other person she had known for that long, and for him to now be gone, it had gnawed a hole clear through to her heart, and she didn't know how to handle it.
"...I wish it had been me," Eliza said softly, to a room full of nobody but puppets.
***
"Where are we even going?" Bea asked as the three women marched across the studio, heading to the trailers in the back.
"You'll see," Michelle said.
"I don't have time for cryptic vagueries today," Bea said sternly.
"You had time to clean my fucking kitchen," Justine said coldly, catching Bea off guard.
"Oh, I'm sorry, was helping you regain sobriety an inconvenience to you?" Bea asked, as Michelle opened the double doors at the back, the three of them continuing to head outwards and towards the trailers, now within sight.
"Do you really think the wisest way to respond to someone drinking to deal with loss they feel responsible for is to antagonize them further on the subject?" Michelle asked, and Bea shut up. Michelle was sounding...like her. Bea should've been proud, but instead, all she felt was even more ire for the woman now.
"Oh, you think...you think that was an inconvenience? Well you know what was a real inconvenience?" Justine asked, "telling a woman so devoted to the craft you'd built that she couldn't be a part of it because of her emotions, things you tell children every day they shoudln't be ashamed to feel or show."
Bea began to snarl through her teeth without saying a word, her insides fuming with rage. How dare Justine think she had the right to speak to her like this. Justine wasn't even really involved in this production, what the fuck was she still even doing in their lives?
"It's appropriate that your age range for your work is small children, considering the way you act," Bea replied sternly, making Justine laugh.
"That's a rich one coming from a woman who talks to puppets on fucking television!" Justine said, "no, ya know what, it actually makes sense you would pretend to be a dog, because you're definitely not a human, and everyone loves dogs, and you need everyone to love you, don't you?"
"You wish the worth of your work remotely rivaled my own," Bea said.
"Unlike you, Beatrice, I don't fucking judge myself based on arbitrary standards of the content I produce, you know why? Because it isn't indicative of my value! We are in the same business, we both make things for kids, the only difference between us is that I recognize that what I do is a job, and you think you're a saint for doing something other hosts have done longer and better than you have and ever could! It's a fucking TV show, get over yourself."
"I'm trying not to hold a lot of what you say in high regard considering you're drunk," Bea said, "but being drunk doesn't give you a license to just insult everyone around you."
"I'm not insulting everyone around me, I'm only. insulting. you," Justine said.
"Guess it was inevitable you'd turn to being an alcoholic, seeing as how you're a writer and all," Bea said.
They finally reached the trailers, as Michelle gathered her key from her pocket and put it into the lock.
"At least I'm not afraid to practice what I preach. You spout all this bullshit about togetherness and understanding, all while hiding everything about yourself, because to allow yourself to be a fully fledged person would mean you're not a faceless entity that children can project themselves onto."
"And what do you preach, exactly? How mommy gets drunk to escape her problems?" Bea asked, and that got it, as Justine turned and socked her in the nose hard. Bea stumbled back down the ramp a little as Justine recoiled in pain, nursing her fist in her hand. Michelle finally got between them.
"Guys! Chill the fuck out!" she shouted, "we are all suffering from the same thing, okay? She died. We all lost her. The last thing we should do is turn against one another."
"Why did you even bring me out here?!" Bea yelled, "she wouldn't be dead if it wasn't for you convincing me that I shouldn't chase after her!"
Michelle couldn't believe her ears. Bea was...blaming...her? Was that...was that what was happening right now?
"You...it was...you think it was my fault?" Michelle asked, her lip quivering, voice broken now, "...I just didn't want you to be stressed."
"Well I'm stressed. I'm stressed every goddamn day now," Bea said, "I was supposed to protect girls like that and you stopped me!"
"Then allow me to fix the goddamn problem!" Michelle shouted back, turning and kicking the door to the trailer open, "enjoy!"
Beatrice's eyes widened in shock. Time itself stood still. No noise penetrated this moment. There, sitting in the trailer before her, was a young woman who looked suspiciously like a mixture of both herself and Liam. No. No no no, there was no way, this couldn't be, how could this be happening? Bea slowly walked in, and Claire looked up from her chair. Bea reached out and slowly, so slowly, put her hand on Claire's cheek. Claire closed her eyes and smiled.
"Mom," she whispered.
Bea turned and looked back at Justine and Michelle, standing in the doorway. She then pulled her hand back and walked up to Michelle, looking her directly in the eyes, before taking her hands in her own.
"Michelle," she whispered.
"I didn't know you blamed me, but I...I guess I was hoping this might be a way I could make up for it. I took a girl away from you, and now I'm giving you this one back. Keagan, of course, is who actually got in touch with her first, but I asked if I could introduce you two, because I knew...I had to atone for my part in Casey's death. We...we built this thing together, you and me and Keagan. Just like you and Liam. We cannot devolve into what we're devolving into, Bea. We just can't. What we have built here is just...it's far too important for that."
"Michelle," Bea said, smiling, squeezing her hand.
"Bea, I'm sorry," Michelle said.
Bea turned and looked back at Claire, before looking back at Michelle, their eyes locked, their whole history lay bare between them. She smiled so wide, making Michelle giggle in response.
"Oh, Michelle," Bea said, "...you're fired."